First post, didn't see my frequent stops here so I had to come and list them.
Cincinnati, OH
Shake It Records - indie/hipster vibe, tons of stock new & old
4156 Hamilton Avenue
Cincinnati, OH 45223
http://www.shakeitrecords.com/
Everybody's Records - more like "your dad's" record store. Lots of used stock, plenty of new though as well.
6106 Montgomery Road
Cincinnati, OH 45213
http://everybodysrecords.com/
Hamilton, OH
Galaxy CD's - tried vinyl in the beginning, not many people seemed interested, now he moved and is starting to get some of the bigger releases again. Always hooks me up with next day or two special orders.
94 N. BROOKWOOD AVE.
HAMILTON, OH, 45013
http://www.galaxydiscs.com/