I got this same copy a few months ago for about $20, and was advertised as the 2007 issue, as well as being the first pressing of the record. I just did some digging and found this old spreadsheet of all the early Victory Records releases. Looks like The Silent Circus did get a pressing back when it was first released: 949 on clear green and 113 were pressed on white.
https://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=p4REm_VxHGG2M6CtMzHlEHA